Skip to main content
CaralogyCaralogy
HomeBrandsRoad TripBudgetDuelGuides
Caralogy

The car comparison platform. Physics simulation, road trips, real costs.

Navigation
All brandsCar duelRunning costsMotorwayMethodology
Simulators
Motorway simulatorRunning costsPerformance duel
Brands
VolkswagenBMWMercedesToyotaTeslaAudi
FRENDEESIT
© 2026 Caralogy · All rights reserved
  1. Home
  2. /Motorway
  3. /compact SUV
AAtto 3vsBScenicBEV
  • MotorwayMotorwayRange and charging
  • PerformancePerformance0-100, top speed
  • ConsumptionConsumptionYearly cost
  • SpecsAtto 3 · Scenic

BYD Atto 3 Extended Range vs Renault Scenic E-Tech Electric 170

Trip mapped at a glance. Charging stops visible, total duration predictable. Caralogy simulation at 130 km/h.

compact SUV · 2022 vs 2024 · Paris → Marseille · 775 km · 130 km/h
BYDBEV

Atto 3 Extended Range

204 ch · 58.5 kWh · 2022

VS
RenaultBEVPlus rapide

Scenic E-Tech Electric 170

170 ch · 55 kWh · 2024

Simulation trip
Assumptions: 130 km/h · start 100 % · mild weather

Result · total trip time

ABYD Atto 3 Extended Range

8h03charging included

3 stops · 56.60 €

Gap13 minin favour of Scenic E-Tech Electric 170
BRenault Scenic E-Tech Electric 170

7h50charging included

5 stops · 74.95 €

Paris → Marseille · 130 km/h · Caralogy simulation
MeasureAtto 3 Extended RangeScenic E-Tech Electric 170Gap
Total time8h037h5013 min · Scenic E-Tech Electric 170
Charging stops3 stops5 stops2 stops · Atto 3 Extended Range
Cost of energy used56.60 €74.95 €18.35 € · Atto 3 Extended Range

Visualise the trip

Both vehicles drive at 130 km/h. The difference comes from charging stops.

BYDBEV
Atto 3 Extended Range
100%
350 km
Range
Paris
0 km · departure
Charge 1
17 min · +23 kWh · 14.04 €
Charge 2
17 min · +23 kWh · 14.04 €
Charge 3
28 min · +35 kWh · 20.99 €
Marseille
775 km · Arrival 8h03
3
Stops
8h03
Duration
56.60 €
Cost of energy used
RenaultBEVFastest
Scenic E-Tech Electric 170
100%
270 km
Range
Paris
0 km · departure
Charge 1
9 min · +22 kWh · 13.20 €
Charge 2
9 min · +22 kWh · 13.20 €
Charge 3
9 min · +22 kWh · 13.20 €
Charge 4
9 min · +22 kWh · 13.20 €
Charge 5
12 min · +27 kWh · 15.91 €
Marseille
775 km · Arrival 7h50
5
Stops
7h50
Duration
74.95 €
Cost of energy used

The 13-minute lead of the Scenic E-Tech Electric 170 does not come from driving speed, but from 2 fewer charging stops on this route (5 vs 3).

Both vehicles drove at 130 km/h for the entire trip. The gap is built at the stops: 5 stops totalling 49 min for the Scenic E-Tech Electric 170 versus 3 stops totalling 62 min for the Atto 3 Extended Range.

Motorway consumption: the Caralogy methodology

The official WLTP figures (15,5 kWh/100km for Atto 3 Extended Range and 16,3 kWh/100km for Scenic E-Tech Electric 170) are measured on a mixed cycle averaging ~46 km/h. At a steady 130 km/h, aerodynamic drag weighs much more heavily - it grows with the square of speed. Caralogy calculates a motorway consumption specific to each vehicle based on its aerodynamic profile (SCx), weight and power curve - not a uniform correction factor. For this trip, the simulation yields 16,7 kWh/100km (Atto 3 Extended Range) and 20,4 kWh/100km (Scenic E-Tech Electric 170). Full methodology: see the assumptions below the controls.

Recovery speed: 11,4 km/min versus 7,9 km/min

During the 49 minutes of charging for the Scenic E-Tech Electric 170, range recovers by 561 km. During the 62 cumulative minutes for the Atto 3 Extended Range, range recovers by 490 km. Per minute: the Scenic E-Tech Electric 170 recovers 1,4× faster. The gap is less pronounced but accumulates over long distances.

For reference: how much would an equivalent petrol car cost?

A Peugeot 3008 1.2 PureTech 130 (equivalent segment) consumes about 7,8 L/100km on the motorway at 130 km/h. At 1,9 €/L, this Paris → Marseille trip would cost ~112 €. That is 2,0× the electric cost of the Atto 3 Extended Range and 1,5× that of the Scenic E-Tech Electric 170. The gap narrows in winter but never reverses.

Energy cost breakdown for your trip Paris → Marseille

The cost per kilometre depends on the electricity rate applied to each segment - based on the energy source used at that point of the trip.

BYD Atto 3 Extended Range

SegmentEnergy usedDistanceConsumption€/kmCost (€)
Paris → Tournus, A6initial energy charged at home · 0.20 €/kWh315 km53 kWh consumed0.033 €/km10.54 €
Tournus, A6 → Limonest, A6energy charged at Ionity 83 kW · 0.60 €/kWh140 km23 kWh consumed0.100 €/km14.04 €
Limonest, A6 → Montélimar, A7energy charged at Ionity 83 kW · 0.60 €/kWh140 km23 kWh consumed0.100 €/km14.04 €
Montélimar, A7 → Marseilleenergy charged at Ionity 75 kW · 0.60 €/kWh179 km30 kWh consumed0.100 €/km17.98 €
Trip total56.60 €

Renault Scenic E-Tech Electric 170

SegmentEnergy usedDistanceConsumption€/kmCost (€)
Paris → Beaune, A6initial energy charged at home · 0.20 €/kWh243 km49 kWh consumed0.041 €/km9.90 €
Beaune, A6 → Tournus, A6energy charged at Ionity 147 kW · 0.60 €/kWh108 km22 kWh consumed0.122 €/km13.20 €
Tournus, A6 → Limonest, A6energy charged at Ionity 147 kW · 0.60 €/kWh108 km22 kWh consumed0.122 €/km13.20 €
Limonest, A6 → Montélimar, A7energy charged at Ionity 147 kW · 0.60 €/kWh108 km22 kWh consumed0.122 €/km13.20 €
Montélimar, A7 → Manosque, A51energy charged at Ionity 147 kW · 0.60 €/kWh108 km22 kWh consumed0.122 €/km13.20 €
Manosque, A51 → Marseilleenergy charged at Ionity 133 kW · 0.60 €/kWh100 km20 kWh consumed0.122 €/km12.24 €
Trip total74.95 €

Range recovered by stop duration

How many kilometres do you recover depending on the time spent at the charger? Comparison at nominal peak power.
Charging stop durationBYD Atto 3 Extended RangeRenault Scenic E-Tech Electric 170
5 minutes-~43 km
10 minutes-~86 km
20 minutes-~172 km
Full session 10 → 80 %-~189 km · 24 min

What produces these figures

WLTP combined consumption
15.5 kWh/100 km · 16.3 kWh/100 km
Net battery
58.5 kWh · 55 kWh

Compare with another vehicle

Replace one of the two with an alternative from the same segment

BYDBEV

Atto 3 Extended Range

204 ch · 58.5 kWh · 2022

RenaultBEV

Scenic E-Tech Electric 170

170 ch · 55 kWh · 2024

Other duels you might be interested in

BYDVSAudi

Atto 3 Extended Range vs Q4 40 e-tron 150 kW

AudiVSRenault

Q4 40 e-tron 150 kW vs Scenic E-Tech Electric 170

BYDVSAudi

Atto 3 Extended Range vs Q4 Sportback 40 e-tron 150 kW

AudiVSRenault

Q4 Sportback 40 e-tron 150 kW vs Scenic E-Tech Electric 170

Frequently asked questions

The advantage comes from the combo real range + charging speed. On Paris → Marseille (775 km at 130 km/h), the Scenic E-Tech Electric 170 arrives in 7h50 with 5 charging stops.

WLTP consumption does not reflect motorway reality. Aerodynamic drag grows with the square of speed, so real consumption is 15 to 25 % higher than WLTP combined. Caralogy calculates a highway consumption specific to each vehicle based on its aerodynamic profile (SCx), weight and power curve.

Total time = driving time + charging time. Driving time is calculated at an average speed of 130 km/h on the motorway (adjustable). Charging time is calculated based on the real power curve of each vehicle, respecting the optimal 10 → 80 % range and the maximum power accepted by the chargers on the route.

No. The displayed cost covers only the energy consumed during the trip: kWh × energy rate, with a mix of home charging and DC fast chargers. Battery wear is a long-term ownership cost, not a trip cost.

On this trip, the energy used costs 56.60 € (Atto 3 Extended Range) and 74.95 € (Scenic E-Tech Electric 170). For reference, an equivalent Peugeot 3008 1.2 PureTech 130 (~7.8 L/100 km) would cost about 112 € in fuel.